Skip to content 
Whether you are hunting, enjoying other outdoor sports or simply taking care of your outdoor property in the cold weather, the right jacket ensures that you are safe and comfortable. It is also important that your jacket does not get in your way, so you want to make sure that it is the proper thickness and material.
A Carhartt jacket can provide protection without inhibiting your movement when you are wearing it. This lets you do things like move around with ease, remain stealthy and meet your goals.
All you have to do is pick the jacket that meets your needs. Looking at the Carhartt J130 vs J131 vs J133 vs J140 is the best place to start.
Quick Comparison: Carhartt J130 Vs J131 Vs J133 Vs J140
| Carhartt Jacket | Insulation | Outer Shell Fabric |
|---|---|---|
| #1. J140 Our Best Pick  Check Price | Quilted Flannel | 12-Ounce Heavyweight Firm Duck Cotton |
#3. J133 Check Price | Arctic Insulation | 1000-Denier Cordura Nylon |
#2. J131 Check Price | Thermal | 12-Ounce Heavyweight Firm Duck Cotton |
#4. J130 Check Price | Quilted Flannel | 12-Ounce Heavyweight Cotton Duck Sandstone |
Outer-Shell Fabric
The outer-shell is one of the most important jacket elements. It determines things like how rugged the jacket is and how warm it will keep you when you are wearing it.
The J130 uses 12-ounce heavyweight sandstone duck cotton. This material is flexible but still has a high degree of toughness.
The J131 uses 12-ounce heavyweight traditional duck cotton. It helps to protect you against the elements since it is a tough canvas material.
The J133 uses 1000-denier cordura nylon. This outer shell is incredibly rugged making it ideal for extreme weather conditions.
The J140 uses 12-ounce heavyweight firm duck cotton. This is the toughest type of outer shell among Carhartt jackets.
Closure Options
All of these jackets have a zipper to close them. This closure type is very easy to use so that you can get out of and into your jacket within seconds. This is important because it ensures that you are not wasting any time when you are doing things like adding or removing layers when you are outside.
The zippers on these jackets are highly durable. Even with repeated and frequent use, you do not have to worry about issues with the zippers getting stuck or coming off of their track.
Insulation
The insulation type plays a major role in the level of protection that you get when you are wearing your jacket outdoors.
The J130 has a quilted flannel lining. This type of insulation is a good choice for temperatures that are above freezing.
The J131 has a thermal lining. This helps to trap body heat so that you are warm. However, it does not allow you to get too hot, especially when you are moving around.
The J133 has arctic insulation. You can use this jacket in arctic temperatures.
The J140 uses quilted flannel insulation. Temperatures that are above freezing are an ideal environment for this jacket.
Additional Features
While the outer-shell fabric and insulation are among the most important considerations, it is also imperative that you are aware of the other features that make these jackets protective.
The J130 does not resist water or wind. However, with drizzling rain, it can still help to keep your inner layers dry.
The J131 is able to resist the wind. Because of this feature, you do not have to worry about chilly winds making it hard to stay warm. You will also stay dry when you are wearing this jacket because it is capable of repelling water.
The J133 provides a very high level of protection against intense winds and rain.
The J140 has several additional features, including being the most rugged of these four jackets. It resists both water and wind.
Best Weather Situation
You want to ensure that you choose a jacket that is ideal for the weather situations that you are facing. This will ensure the proper level of protection against Mother Nature.
The J130 is a good choice when you are working in a cold environment. For example, if you work in freezers or you go back and forth between indoor and outdoor environments at work.
The J131 is a good choice for a mild winter environment. When temperatures are ranging from 40 to 50 degrees Fahrenheit, this jacket will keep you warm without causing you to overheat.
The J133 can protect you in dangerous, arctic weather conditions. You can wear it comfortably when the temperatures are in the negatives.
The J140 is ideal for temperatures that are cold and wet. It can keep your warm in temperatures that are below freezing.
Stiffness and Breaking It In
All of these jackets have different levels of flexibility. Those that are stiffer require a little longer to break in. It is important to break them in before you wear them for outdoor sports and chores so that your movement is not restricted.
The J130 is designed to not need to be broken in. This means that you can start wearing it full-time as soon as you get it.
The J131 comes relatively flexible. Most people do not need to spend any time breaking it in.
The J133 is relatively loose despite its very rugged features. Within a day or two, you can break it in completely.
The J140 is a little on the stiffer side. This is due to how rugged the materials of the jacket are. However, with regular wear for about a week, you are able to break it in without a problem.
Conclusion
After comparing the Carhartt J130 vs J131 vs J133 vs J140, you can better see which of these jackets is most suitable for your needs. All of these jackets are ideal, but the J140 stands out above the rest of them.
The Carhartt J140 is very tough and can withstand cold temperature extremes. Its quilted flannel lining will keep you warm without being overly stuffy.
This jacket will not restrict your movements and it is relatively easy to break in. The duck cotton outer shell is highly durable. Other features of this jacket that make it ideal for a variety of outdoor adventures include it being highly rugged, resistant to water and it is able to repel the wind so that harsh winds do not make you cold.